How Many Unpaid Claims Are Sitting in Your A/R Right Now?


Most practice owners can name their total A/R. Fewer can say how many claims in it haven't been touched in 30 days. Those are the claims that age into write-offs, and they're easy to miss when follow-up happens only when someone has a free afternoon.
Here's how to find them, how often to follow up, and how to keep A/R follow-up on schedule into year-end.
What is accounts receivable follow-up?
Accounts receivable follow-up is the work of chasing unpaid claims until they're paid, corrected, appealed, or closed. It includes checking claim status with payers, fixing and resubmitting rejected claims, working denials, filing appeals, and moving patient balances to statements. Good A/R follow-up happens on a schedule, not when a claim finally looks old enough to worry about.
How do you find the unpaid claims sitting in your A/R?
Run your A/R aging report by payer, not only in total.
Filter for claims with no activity in the last 30 days.
Count the claims, not only the dollars. Ten small claims can take more work than one large one.
Pull your open denial list and check which denials haven't been worked.
Flag any claim close to that payer's timely filing deadline.
The number from step 2 is your untouched A/R. That's the number to bring down.
How often should you follow up on unpaid claims?
Set a follow-up action for every aging bucket.
Claim age | Follow-up action |
0 to 30 days | Confirm the payer received the claim and fix any clearinghouse rejections |
31 to 60 days | Check claim status with the payer and log the reference number |
61 to 90 days | Correct and resubmit, or start an appeal |
91 to 120 days | Escalate with the payer and check timely filing and appeal deadlines |
Over 120 days | Decide: appeal, bill the patient, or write off |
Denials skip the line. MGMA recommends working denials daily, starting with high-dollar claims and the closest appeal deadlines.
Why does untouched A/R cost more the longer it sits?
Older claims get harder to collect. An MGMA study found more than half of denied claims never get reworked, as reported in FPM. Some payers allow as few as 15 to 30 days to file, and a missed deadline is usually a write-off.
MGMA's 2025 Financials and Operations data shows the gap. In 2024, physician-owned practices grew the share of A/R in the 0 to 30 day bucket and kept 120+ day balances mostly flat. Hospital-owned groups saw their 120+ day share rise 9.5 to 15.9 points, and reported bad debt of $43,073 to $48,337 per physician, per MGMA.
How do you work A/R in a PT practice?
Therapy claims stall for reasons other specialties see less often. Check these first when a PT, OT, or SLP claim sits unpaid:
Visits billed past the authorized count or date range
Visit limits reached for the plan year
Missing KX modifier on Medicare claims past the yearly threshold
Plan of care certification missing or out of date
Wrong or missing therapy modifiers
How do you keep A/R follow-up on schedule?
Assign each payer to one person, so every claim has an owner.
Block daily time for denials and weekly time for the aging report.
Log every touch with the date, what was done, and the payer reference number.
Track how old your open denials are. MGMA lists denial follow-up age as a workload measure that shows when a team is stretched thin.
Review aging by payer before contract talks, so you know which payers pay slowest.
How does Rockstar help with A/R follow-up?
Rockstar places vetted, highly experienced medical billing VAs with private practices. They work your aging report, check claim status, rework denials, and file appeals on schedule. You manage the VA day to day. Rockstar handles payroll, benefits, and replacements.
Only 37% of VA candidates pass Rockstar's selection.
Every VA is matched to your practice through a proprietary matching system built on three assessments.
Rockstar VAs reach a 98% retention rate, so your A/R follow-up doesn't restart with every new hire.
Practices save around $20,000 a year per role compared with a local hire.
More than 300 Rockstar VAs work across private practices in the USA.
Want to learn more about our proprietary matching system? Learn more by clicking here.
Want to see what a medical billing VA handles? See our solutions here.
Get your A/R moving
Tell us how much of your A/R is past 60 days, and we'll show you what a Rockstar billing VA would take on.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between a rejected claim and a denied claim?
A rejected claim never made it into the payer's system, usually because of a data error caught by the clearinghouse or payer, like a wrong member ID. You fix it and resubmit. A denied claim was processed and the payer refused to pay. A denial needs a correction, a reconsideration, or an appeal, and it has its own deadlines.
How often should I run an A/R aging report?
Weekly, sorted by payer. A weekly report catches a payer slowing down or a batch of claims stuck at the clearinghouse before they age into the next bucket. Review the trend monthly to see whether your 90+ and 120+ day balances are growing or shrinking. Look at claim counts as well as dollars.
When should I write off an unpaid claim?
After you've exhausted the appeal options, confirmed the patient doesn't owe the balance, and the cost of more follow-up is higher than what you'd collect. Set a written write-off policy with dollar thresholds and approval rules, so write-offs are decisions, not defaults. Review write-offs monthly to find the denial reasons behind them.
Can a virtual assistant handle A/R follow-up?
Yes. Rockstar places medical billing VAs who work aging reports, check claim status, rework denials, and file appeals. You manage the work day to day, and Rockstar handles payroll, benefits, and replacements. Only 37% of candidates pass Rockstar's selection, and Rockstar VAs reach a 98% retention rate.



